Property tax rankings: 25 Upstate NY counties getting the most bang for their buck

Property taxes fund all manner of services in your community, but not every community apportions them, or benefits from them, the same way.

A new study from SmartAsset ranks New York's counties according to which residents get the most bang for their buck from their property taxes. The ranking uses property tax rate, crime rates, local school ratings and other factors to create an overall value index for each county in the state.

Take a look to see which Upstate NY counties get the most from their property taxes below.

Take a look to see which Upstate NY counties get the most from their property taxes below.

For more on methodology, visit SmartAsset.com.

Jeff Goulding for NYup.com

#25 Columbia County

State rank: #31
National rank: #2128

Property tax rate: 1.90%
School rating: 6.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1809

#24 Orleans County

State rank: #30
National rank: #2127

Property tax rate: 3.46%
School rating: 4.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1682

#23 Warren County

State rank: #28
National rank: #2097

Property tax rate: 1.63%
School rating: 5.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1391

Matthew Digati for NYup.com

#22 Niagara County

State rank: #27
National rank: #2091

Property tax rate: 2.99%
School rating: 9.00
Crimes per 100K people: 3104

Stephen D. Cannerelli | scannerelli@syracuse.com

#21 Seneca County

State rank: #26
National rank: #2090

Property tax rate: 2.83%
School rating: 5.00
Crimes per 100K people: 2259

Kathe Harrington for NYup.com

#20 Allegany County

State rank: #25
National rank: #2081

Property tax rate: 3.28%
School rating: 3.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1654

Matthew Digati for NYup.com

#19 Cattaraugus County

State rank: #23
National rank: #2041

Property tax rate: 3.06%
School rating: 5.00
Crimes per 100K people: 2230

Scott Schild | sschild@syracuse.com

#18 Wyoming County

State rank: #22
National rank: #2038

Property tax rate: 2.79%
School rating: 3.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1231

Lauren Long | llong@syracuse.com

#17 Cayuga County

State rank: #21
National rank: #2037

Property tax rate: 2.55%
School rating: 5.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1914

Jeff Goulding for NYup.com

#16 Delaware County

State rank: #20
National rank: #2033

Property tax rate: 1.95%
School rating: 4.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1716

Scott Schild | sschild@syracuse.com

#15 Genesee County

State rank: #19
National rank: #2007

Property tax rate: 2.86%
School rating: 7.00
Crimes per 100K people: 2466

Michael Greenlar | mgreenlar@syracuse.com

#14 Steuben County

State rank: #17
National rank: #1974

Property tax rate: 2.77%
School rating: 4.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1549

Courtesy of Hunter Mountain

#13 Greene County

State rank: #16
National rank: #1939

Property tax rate: 1.70%
School rating: 4.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1482

syracuse.com

#12 Herkimer County

State rank: #15
National rank: #1903

Property tax rate: 2.50%
School rating: 5.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1862

Gary Walts | gwalts@syracuse.com

#11 Livingston County

State rank: #13
National rank: #1859

Property tax rate: 2.82%
School rating: 6.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1679

Michael Greenlar | mgreenlar@syracuse.com

#10 Jefferson County

State rank: #12
National rank: #1822

Property tax rate: 1.64%
School rating: 5.00
Crimes per 100K people: 2016

syracuse.com

#9 Ontario County

State rank: #11
National rank: #1811

Property tax rate: 2.43%
School rating: 8.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1917

Gary Walts | gwalts@syracuse.com

#8 Oneida County

State rank: #8
National rank: #1780

Property tax rate: 2.53%
School rating: 9.00
Crimes per 100K people: 2547

Gary Walts | gwalts@syracuse.com

#7 Lewis County

State rank: #7
National rank: #1771

Property tax rate: 1.74%
School rating: 3
Crimes per 100K people: 1220

Mike Lynch for NYup.com

#6 Clinton County

State rank: #6
National rank: #1653

Property tax rate: 2.00%
School rating: 7.00
Crimes per 100K people: 2038

David Lassman | syracuse.com

#5 Saratoga County

State rank: #5
National rank: #1581

Property tax rate: 1.61%
School rating: 8
Crimes per 100K people: 1391

Michelle Heimerman for NYup.com

#4 Putnam County

State rank: #4
National rank: #1477

Property tax rate: 2.51%
School rating: 10.00
Crimes per 100K people: 776

Provided photo

#3 Otsego County

State rank: #3
National rank: #1416

Property tax rate: 1.80%
School rating: 6.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1360

syracuse.com

#2 Madison County

State rank: #2
National rank: #1413

Property tax rate: 2.46%
School rating: 8.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1593

Scott Schild | sschild@syracuse.com

#1 Essex County

State rank: #1
National rank: #1174

Property tax rate: 1.72%
School rating: 7.00
Crimes per 100K people: 1156

Cookie Settings

Disclaimer

Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, (updated 8/1/2024) and acknowledgement of our Privacy Policy, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (updated 7/1/2024).

© 2024 Advance Local Media LLC. All rights reserved (About Us).
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local.

Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site.

YouTube's privacy policy is available here and YouTube's terms of service is available here.